21 Comments
User's avatar
Cam Craig's avatar

That eha tweet and accompanying city journal article confused me a bit up until I read the part about how we should get rid of USAID because hey, you don’t know those people, so their moral worth to you isn’t much.

HaroldWilson's avatar

>(i) Dylan Matthews’ Vox post on how the cost of repairing Notre Dame could instead have saved 47,500 lives;

Despite being generally in agreement with many EA positions (have taken the pledge etc.), I understand people's objections here because it smacks a bit of hypocrisy. Clearly, Dylan Matthews does not live his life in ascetic poverty to give as much money as possible to malaria nets, and his comments have an unsavory hectoring tone that makes him look silly. I have no doubt he spends money on many more frivolous things than restoring Notre Dame, so the browbeating comes across a bit nasty.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

Fair enough! iirc, he was responding to someone who had claimed that we "couldn't compare" cathedral repairs to saving lives, so he was just showing how we literally can (and why, in his view, the life-saving option is better). I don't think he would claim that his personal spending is *morally better* than saving lives. My view of these things is that we're all a bit selfish and it isn't very productive to fuss too much about that. By contrast, it seems more reasonable to try to push for moral optimality when people are *specifically trying to do good/selfless things* — and it's reasonable to expect people to do this at least a moderate amount.

Of course, if someone just views their donations to cathedral repairs as more like a personal hobby than a moral act (and they satisfy their duties of beneficence elsewhere), then this move would no longer apply.

There's also a reasonable criticism of this move that we shouldn't want to make extra (suboptimal but still helpful) moral acts *more subject to criticism* than extra personal spending. For this reason, I'm inclined to agree that a "browbeating" tone isn't ideal, even though I sympathize with his frustration that most people do next to nothing to help the global poor and misconstrue comparatively ineffective forms of "altruism" as adequate substitutes. I'd feel much better about someone's ineffective altruism if I knew that they'd already made serious efforts towards effectiveness on other occasions.

fwiw, Matthews himself is, afaict, actually really unusually altruistic. He literally donated a kidney to a stranger. So that may also temper your sense of "hypocrisy". I think he's very genuine (and arguably has standing to feel frustrated by the rest of us)!

HaroldWilson's avatar

I think the issue is that the terms he used come across a very accusatory. As he said:

"It’s useful to imagine walking down Main Street, stopping at each table at the diner Lou’s, shaking hands with as many people as you can, and telling them, ‘I think you need to die to make a cathedral pretty"

I think the message any observer not fully bought into EA will not unreasonably take away is 'Dylan Matthews thinks I am a murderer for donating to Notre Dame'. And even if Matthews is, as is no doubt the case, more altruistic than 99.9% of people, it will still come across as hypocrisy (does he mentally chastise himself in these terms every time he buys something other than gruel?)

And while I sort of accept the distinction between intended-selfish and intended-altruistic acts, it does leave us in the difficult position of trying to say that donating to save and restore a cathedral is somehow more worthy of scrutiny than spending 'selfishly'.

I think the only way to avoid this is to eschew zero sum langauge. So rather than say 'it is unconscionable to donate money to Notre Dame while African children perish', say 'look what great things we can achieve with global acts of altruism, let us attack malaria (or whatever) in the same way'.

Generally, the problem is that saying deliberately edgy things like the above is rewarded in some online circles, but most people one just sounds like a freak.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

I agree the positive framing is better!

Alex Laine's avatar

I really enjoyed your article! I’m trying to figure out what to donate to: Do you think we have good enough metrics to scale the suffering of beings like humans—>cows—>chickens—>shrimp? What if it’s actually like a logarithm or something? The sheer numbers and seeming intensity in cases like factory farming pull me, but so do the plights of children who will die (and their families!). I’m not sure quite how to work this out and I don’t know how great something like neuron counting really is. Thank you.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

It's very hard to know! In light of the uncertainty, a portfolio approach seems pretty appealing to me, as described here: https://www.goodthoughts.blog/p/subagents-for-shrimp

Alex Laine's avatar

Thank you very much!

Thersitism's avatar

When people complain about longtermism, insects, etc., isn't it better (in most cases) to tell them to donate to public health, rather than argue about the merits? Obviously your Substack audience is another matter.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

Probably helpful to have a bit of both, at least in public discourse. Even when people aren't receptive to changing their priorities, arguments may influence public perception of which views are at least *reasonable* vs worth sneering dismissal.

Tanya Polarbear's avatar

Nice article as usual. I’m sure you have a million better things to write about but I’d be interested in your publishing your take on the recent response to singer’s article by nefsky and tenenbaum, which i found pretty convincing

J.ai's avatar

Treating an argument as a threat makes it easy to defend an identity instead of examine one premise. Your modular approach matters because revising a belief needn’t mean surrendering everything. I’ve been exploring that difficulty in my own reasoning. https://jaiisyourman.substack.com/p/the-beliefs-i-cannot-trace

Written with AI, drawing on my essay.

Joshua Luyali Wangia's avatar

The core is nearly indisputable, yet almost nobody acts on it.

I'd add that the core proves more than the movement actually tries to do. If impartial beneficence is right, and sympathy must not set moral status, then the reason a life is so cheap to save in one place and not in another is no fact of nature or unfortunate turn of events

It is literally an institution we built and can build differently. We assign citizenship at birth, and it determines how well your rights and material conditions are protected and distributed. Giving ten percent treats the symptom well, but without the intent to replace or reform the system, it leaves the proverbial bathwater running. I'd say impartiality is the baby here; and the bathwater is highkey the assumption that donation alone can save it.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

Depends what you donate to. You could donate to political lobbying campaigns for open borders, for example, if you really thought that would be more effective. But given the strength of voter hostility to the idea, I (sadly) doubt it would achieve much.

Joshua Luyali Wangia's avatar

I agree. I think donating something like your life’s work to a cause is more effective.

Is donation really more powerful than belief? Deeply held beliefs shape your actions over your whole life and the consequences change everywhere down the line. It’s my intuition that being an EA abolitionist during American Slavery would mean significantly more than donating.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

It depends on the empirical details of one's specific social context and skill set; what method is most promising for improving the world is not something that can be answered a priori and universally.

Probably important to clarify that nothing in EA says that donation is the *only* means of doing good. It is just one extremely powerful and widely neglected option.

Another major area of focus within EA is precisely career choice - "your life's work", as you say. Check out, e.g., https://80000hours.org/career-guide/

(But asking people to change their entire life focus risks being *far* more demanding than asking them to at least donate 10% to good causes. So I tend to focus more on the latter, less onerous, ask.)

Joshua Luyali Wangia's avatar

I agree with the context based decision

making. What I do think can be answered universally and sometimes a priori is what people ought to believe, which I think EA and utilitarianism as a whole has an unstable base upon which to claim, though i respect the usefulness and good consequences of both systems.

I think abolitionists would context-based fight slavery in context dependent ways, but need to believe in abolitionism first, and through this belief their motives and actions are shaped by their context.

Jesus of Nazareth and his disciples have interesting things to say about this. Probably an article coming on this somewhat lol.

Mephistophilis's avatar

I'll tell you one thing that might annoy people about EA. Many of us are old enough to have been thinking about Singer's ideas and effective giving before Effective Altruism was ever a thing. It is frankly quite irritating to be told that EA is simply about optimal charitable giving as if they invented the idea. So EA *must* be more that that which is where the disagreements manifest.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

Your "as if" is doing a lot of (straw-manning) work there! Nobody is claiming to have "invented the idea" of effective giving. What we're doing is *coordinating* with others to form a *movement* around the idea: e.g. pledging 10% to effective charities and encouraging others to do likewise. If you think that's a bad idea, feel free to explain your disagreement further. If you agree that it's a good idea, then by all means join in! But feeling irritated that other people are acting on ideas that you previously thought about is patently unreasonable.

(Various people involved have also developed more specific ideas about *how* best to do good effectively, which one can assess on a case-by-case basis. But if you want to assess what's novel about EA, I'd point to the institutions: Giving What We Can, 80 000 Hours, GiveWell, etc.)

Mephistophilis's avatar

I absolutely agree the institutions are the novelty but then effective giving *isn't* the core of EA that most people are rejecting. It is the more specific ideas about how to give effectively.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

I think most people don't want to donate 10% of their incomes anywhere, frankly, and/or don't really care enough to spend social capital on encouraging others to give effectively. But it'd be great if they'd prove me wrong by setting up a competing movement with slightly different ideas about giving effectively! Compare: https://www.goodthoughts.blog/p/the-strange-shortage-of-moral-optimizers